Fitness does not always equal metabolic health

You might work out regularly, eat clean, and maintain a healthy body weight. On the surface, it all appears to be working. However, beneath that disciplined exterior, your cells might not be responding to insulin as they should. This early dysfunction can quietly impact energy levels, recovery capacity, hormone regulation, and long-term health outcomes.

This condition is known as insulin resistance. It is widely misunderstood as something that only affects people who are sedentary or overweight. In reality, it can develop in individuals who are lean and active. Factors such as chronic stress, irregular sleep patterns, nutrient timing issues, and high glycemic food choices can all contribute.

What is insulin resistance

Insulin is a hormone that allows your cells to absorb glucose from your bloodstream for energy use. When cells stop responding efficiently to insulin, glucose remains in circulation. The pancreas then compensates by releasing more insulin, which over time leads to inflammation, fatigue, and impaired metabolic function.

This condition can exist years before traditional blood markers begin to flag any concern. Many people with normal body weight and healthy lifestyles may be living with subclinical insulin resistance without realizing it.

‍

‍

Why fit people are not immune

A growing body of research shows that normal-weight individuals can still be metabolically unhealthy. This profile is sometimes referred to as TOFI, which stands for Thin Outside, Fat Inside. These individuals might have a healthy BMI but exhibit high levels of visceral fat, blood sugar instability, or chronic inflammation.

Common contributors include excessive endurance training without sufficient muscle-building activity, ongoing psychological stress, disrupted circadian rhythms, frequent consumption of refined carbohydrates, or lack of sufficient recovery.

Early signs to watch for

Subtle indicators often appear before blood sugar levels become abnormal. Recognizing them early can help you make adjustments before insulin resistance becomes harder to reverse.

• Midday energy crashes or foggy thinking after meals
• Persistent hunger or cravings despite adequate food intake
• Stubborn abdominal fat that does not respond to training
• Slightly elevated fasting glucose or HbA1c even if still within "normal" range
• A daily dependence on caffeine to feel alert in the morning

How to reverse early insulin resistance

Insulin sensitivity is highly adaptable and can improve quickly with targeted lifestyle changes. Here are four strategies supported by current evidence.

Focus on strength training over fasted cardio
Muscle tissue is the primary site for glucose disposal. While fasted cardio can support fat oxidation, it is not ideal as a dominant training style when managing insulin sensitivity. Strength training builds muscle mass, which increases your body's ability to use insulin efficiently.

Start your day with protein and fat
A protein-rich breakfast reduces morning glucose spikes and keeps you satiated longer. Including healthy fats further supports blood sugar stability. Avoid meals that are carbohydrate-heavy and low in fiber or protein, especially first thing in the morning.

Get natural morning light exposure
Morning sunlight helps regulate circadian rhythms, which play a role in hormonal balance and metabolic control. Aim to get outside within an hour of waking for at least ten to fifteen minutes.

Manage stress intentionally
Chronic stress elevates cortisol, which can block insulin’s effects and encourage fat storage. Tools like nasal breathing, cold water immersion, walking in nature, or simple mindfulness practices help restore nervous system balance and improve glucose regulation.

‍

‍

Consider clinical testing

If you suspect you may be dealing with insulin resistance, ask your healthcare provider about more specific tests. Beyond fasting glucose, the following markers can offer better insight.

• Fasting insulin
• HbA1c
• HOMA-IR (a calculation that combines glucose and insulin levels)
• Continuous glucose monitoring for post-meal trends

Even if results are within traditional ranges, subtle elevations or trends can help you take early action.

The bottom line

Being fit does not guarantee optimal metabolic function. Insulin resistance can develop silently in those who appear healthy, especially when under chronic stress, consuming processed carbohydrates, or lacking sufficient recovery and resistance training.

The earlier you recognize the signs, the easier it is to course-correct. Strength training, quality food choices, light exposure, and stress management are all powerful levers. Small, consistent actions done with awareness can restore insulin sensitivity and support long-term energy, resilience, and performance.